Haley
Barr May 10, 2015
Chemistry
E/F odd Mr. Ippolito
Schwartz, John. "Recycled Drinking Water: Getting Past
the Yuck Factor." The New York Times 8 May 2015: n. pag. Print.
The article
“Recycled Drinking Water: Getting Past the Yuck Factor,” by John Schwartz,
describes the push to use recycled water for drinking in the midst of serious
droughts being faced in the U.S. Previous methods of coping with drought
included conserving more water or using desalination to turn abundant sources
of water, like the Pacific Ocean, into drinking water. Now, ideas of conserving
water that were put aside because they were too expensive, controversial, or
unpleasant are being relooked at, including recycling water that has been
already used by residents. Water recycling is already used to irrigate crops or
deliver water to golf courses, zoos, or farms, but “enticing people to drink
recycled water, however, requires getting past what experts call the “yuck
factor.” Previous efforts to encourage water reuse in the 1990s have failed,
mainly because the effort was called “toilet to tap,” which many people thought
was unappealing. Now, people have begun to warm up to the idea, with a special
wastewater treatment plant in Orange County that puts used water through several
stages of purification that leaves it “cleaner than anything that flows out of
a home faucet or comes in a brand- name bottle.” The process includes
microfiltration that strains out anything larger than .2 microns, including
almost all suspended solids, bacteria, and protozoa, and after that, reverse
osmosis is used to remove other impurities, like viruses, pharmaceuticals, and
dissolved minerals. Water reuse is also being tried in other places of the
country besides California without incident, such as some very dry cities in
Texas. As Marty Adams, the head of the
water system for the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, says, “The
difference between this and 2000 is everyone wants this to happen.”
The reuse of
water for drinking has a big impact on people, especially now because of the
extremely harsh drought in California and the mandatory water usage
restrictions imposed last month by Governor Jerry Brown. During this current
drought, Orange County just completed a $142 million expansion that will
increase capacity by more than 30 percent, to 100 million gallons a day, and
“at a fraction of the cost of importing water or desalinating seawater.”
Filtered reused water is even cleaner than normal tap water, and is “stripped
down to the H, 2, and the O.” The reuse of water allows a cheaper and cleaner
way of combatting drinking water shortages in places across America. This
method of obtaining clean water by reuse may be even more common in the future,
and it is an important step in conservation efforts in America.
I really
enjoyed reading this article. It was
interesting to read, and informed me of a recent water conservation effort that
I did not know existed. I liked how the author included lots of information
about the benefits of recycled water, but also why this method of reusing water
has not worked until now. I also liked the pictures the author included of the
purification plants and important people working on the water reuse effort. The
author could improve his article, however, by including more information about
the purification process. He does write what is removed from the water during
purification, but fails to mention how. Other than this, I thought the author
wrote a great article that was interesting to read. I hope other states and
counties follow the examples of places that have already implemented this
method of reuse, as it saves money and water, one of the most valuable
resources we have.
Haley's article was very well written. I was very surprised to learn the U.S is going through a hard time and facing a lot of droughts. Haley did an excellent job of including direct quotes from the article to allow us to see all the positive reaction that is coming from this idea of recycling water. Haley also included a great topic sentence. It was nicely written and set up the main of idea of her article nicely. I liked Haley's argument that water conservation is important to our country and that this article helps stress the importance.If I could add anything to this review, it would be to explain what exactly water recycling is. Haley could've included that it was a process where wastewater is reused. I also wish Haley included why water recycling was created and if it helped the problem it was created for. That would allow for a more convincing argument on why we should use water recycling. Overall,Haley did an excellent job on her review of the article,"
ReplyDeleteRecycled Drinking Water: Getting Past the Yuck Factor" and helped me understand the impact recycling water could have.
Cindy Kwok
ReplyDelete5/12/15
Schwartz, John. "Recycled Drinking Water: Getting Past the Yuck Factor." The New York Times 8 May 2015: n. pag. Print.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/12/science/recycled-drinking-water-getting-past-the-yuck-factor.html?ref=science
I reviewed Haley’s critique of the article of the article “Recycled Drinking Water: Getting Past the Yuck Factor.” Haley did a great job introducing the article and what it was about. I liked how she included what methods were used before when the droughts occurred and why those methods weren’t the best way to deal with droughts, whether because it was too expensive or because people just didn’t like the methods and how people are starting to “reintroduce” these ideas. People are starting to get used to the idea of conserving water and reusing it because there are new ways to help purify the water that takes out all the bacteria. It was a good idea to include quotes to help explain why people are reusing water and it makes the article stronger. This is a very important topic right now especially since (as Haley mentioned in her review), there are many recent droughts that have been happening around California and it is important since there are millions of people who live there and the drought can affect them all. I agree with Haley on where the article did good and the improvements it can make. I’m glad I read this article because it helped inform me of what as going on in California and the ways that people are trying o save water. I think it is an important article because many people tend to waste water like crazy such as leaving the sink on and we don’t really think about how badly people who are living in California or other places that get droughts need the water.